Donizetti: L’elisir d’amore

Glyndebourne Tour: Marlowe Theatre, Canterbury

Last month my granddaughter, aged 8, saw this production at Glyndebourne. It was her first opera but she was well prepared because the company had done some outreach work in her Brighton primary school (Hurrah!). She was thrilled with the production and having now seen it I can see why. It is huge fun and immaculately well staged and sung.

The oblique frontage to Adina’s house provided by Les Brotherston’s set leaves plenty of room to accommodate the large and fine chorus which Donizetti’s score makes more use of than earlier composers such as Mozart.

Nardus Williams is terrific as the attractive but hard-to-get Adina wanted in marriage by two men, one of whom is a cad (Matthew Durkan – good) and the other is clearly the one she should have (Sehoon Moon of whom more anon). Her top notes soar, her emotional control is excellent and her duets are delightful.

Moon (tenor) is boyish and very appealing dramatically. And his last famous aria, over harp and clarinet, just before Adina finally sees sense is the showstopper it should be. All in all his is a very memorable performance.

Also outstanding is Misha Kiria as the Dr Dulcamara – all those fabulous bass patter songs unfurled at high speed with clarity and insouciant panache. He looks comical too because he dwarfs everyone else.

Much of this performance reminded me of a comment made by Michael Berkeley in his recent Private Passions with psychotherapist, Philippa Perry on Radio 3. He explained to her that traditionally, before the mid nineteenth century, almost every emotion in opera was expressed in a vibrant 3/4 rhythm, (oom-pa-pa). This show is almost a case study to prove his point which is partly why it swings along so cheerfully.

I was delighted to see lots of very engaged school parties at the matinee I attended. Ironically what, I suspect, most of them will remember most is the performance by mime artist, Maxine Nourissat as Dr Dulcamara’s assistant, Puck to the other man’s Oberon. It’s a non-singing part but he commands the stage for every second he’s on it whether he’s dancing, prancing, twitching, gesturing, “talking” with his very expressive hands or twirling an umbrella in the colours of the Italian flag.

Susan Elkin

Mendelssohn: Elijah

CBSO, Birmingham Symphony Hall, 7 November 2019

Since it first opened I have always though the Symphony Hall the finest acoustic in the country for large scale choral works and so it proved once again for a magnificent performance of Elijah this week. Kazuki Yamada brings a dramatic realism to his interpretation, combined with the subtlest of musical nuances, so that the combination is thrilling. There is clarity throughout – many orchestral passages sparkle with the lucidity of the writing – while the constant ebb and flow of the musical line heightens the intensity of the experience.

Yamada is not afraid of the extrovert impact of the score, with the Baal choruses and Be not afraid as heart on sleeve as one could wish, while the gentle uplift of Lift thine eyes is floated effortlessly into the open spaces of the hall.

The CBSO chorus were on fine form, with incisive accuracy and a real sense of enthusiasm, combined with immediate response to their conductor’s wishes. The CBSO itself lives up to its international reputation and it is always worth coming to Birmingham to hear them on their home turf.

They were also blessed on this occasion with outstanding soloists. Matthew Brook proved to be surely the finest exponent of Elijah at present available. Not only does he sing the part with exemplary beauty but he brings a dramatic dynamism to it which is utterly convincing. Where there is a move to stage oratorios today, a performance of this quality makes any extra staging quite unnecessary. Karen Cargill was certainly his match, bringing beauty of line to O rest in the Lord while giving us one of the nastiest Jezebel’s I can recall! The change in tonality and rasp was particularly impressive. If the other two soloists don’t have quite the same scope Robert Murray showed the lyricism he can bring to If with all your heart and Keri Fuge was a moving widow.

Elijah can too easily be dismissed as an old war-horse trotted out to fill a choral gap. Done like this one can only thrill at the experience – and we still have Gerontius to come!

Brighton Philharmonic at Brighton Dome, Sun 10th November, 2.45pm

The Brighton Phil’s 2019/20 exciting season opener at Brighton Dome on Sunday 10th November showcases the violin in its many guises and blurs the boundaries of classical, tango, jazz and gypsy folk music. We are delighted to welcome violinist Christian Garrick and friends (from his Budapest Café Orchestra and the Christian Garrick Quartet) for what promises to be a memorable collaboration with the Brighton Philharmonic Strings.

Christian Garrick is no stranger to Brighton audiences as he performed Astor Piazzolla’s brilliant and evocative re-working of Vivaldi’s Four Seasons at Brighton Dome with the Brighton Phil under Barry Wordsworth in 2006. He is very excited to be performing it again, alongside Piazzolla’s sultry Libertango, one of the composer’s most performed works with a fiendishly familiar melody full of the spicy rhythms of his native Argentina.

Christian is an improvising violinist, composer and bandleader, who is professor of jazz and non-classical violin at three of London’s major music conservatoires, and has made a huge name for himself as a self-styled “Violin Operator”. He is joined on stage by David Gordon on the piano and melodica, Richard Pryce on double bass, Tom Hooper on drums and percussion, Eddie Hession on button accordion, and Adrian Zolotuhin on guitar, saz and domra.

The great jazz saxophonist and composer Sir John Dankworth wrote his bluesy jazz Violin Concerto for Christian in 2005, a rhythmic and expansive piece that bounds along in the spirit of Gershwin’s great jazz orchestral works, centred on the solo violin and a classic piano-bass-drums jazz trio. Christian writes:

“John Dankworth was a guiding figure from an early point in my life. Dad was pianist with Cleo Laine and John for a while in the 1970’s and I went on many of their Wavendon music courses over the years, during which time, John introduced me (aged 10) to a young Nigel Kennedy (25) which ensued in an unforgettable all-out fiddle jazz duel!  Latterly I’ve performed and recorded numerously with the Dankworths so I was honoured that John wrote his concerto with me in mind right after he’d finished one for clarinet for Emma Johnson.”

Another treat will be an orchestral suite of Anne Dudley’s Poldark score. Christian has been playing the solo violin parts for the BBC’s Poldark since the series began in 2015. Oscar-winning composer Anne Dudley scored the beautiful theme tune for Christian to play while the opening and closing credits roll.

The concert will also feature original pieces composed by Christian and a helping of folk-gypsy hijinks from members of the Budapest Café Orchestra, some of whom will be joining us fresh from their 10th anniversary tour.

Tickets from £14.50-£42.50 (50% discount for students/Under 18s) are available from Brighton Dome Ticket Office in Church Street, (01273) 709709 and online: www.brightondome.org

Discounted parking for Brighton Phil concert attendees can be found in NCP Church Street Car Park, a couple of minutes’ walk from the Dome, costing just £6 between 1pm & 6pm.

The Brighton Phil’s next concert, on Sunday 1st December, presents a cornucopia of classics, conducted by Natalie Murray-Beale and featuring Thomas Gould (violin) performing Vaughan Williams’ evocative The Lark Ascending.

 

 

Hastings Philharmonic

Christ Church, St Leonards, Saturday 2 November 2019

An evening of choral works opened with Finzi’s beautiful Romance for Strings. Almost unknown in comparison to similar works by Elgar or Vaughan Williams, it is a masterpiece of quiet tact and understated joy. We could almost have done with hearing it twice to impress upon us just how lovely it is.

However we were then straight in to Britten Saint Nicolas, with Jonathan Cooke the eponymous saint. His heroic and forceful tones, so different from Peter Pears for whom it was written, gave the whole a cutting edge and urgency which was impressive and seemed to galvanise all the other singers. The men’s chorus were particularly strong in the journey to Palestine with the higher ladies voices adding the waves and the angels. The work may have been written with amateurs in mind but there is nothing simplistic about the writing which is highly demanding throughout. None more so than the parts for younger voices, and here they were very young voices! Antonio Ulucan da Silva sang Nicolas as a boy with authority and passion. He was joined by his younger sister Lara, and Lucy and Matthew Rayner to make up the pickled boys’ chorus. Once again the clarity and purity of sound was exactly what Britten requires.

The percussion came into their own in the final sections, with some bombastic tam-tam playing to bring the whole to a glorious conclusion. Britten includes two hymns for congregational use. In Noye this is normally taken up enthusiastically. On this occasion the audience may have loved the performance but seemed less than willing to sing when asked to do so.

After the interval we heard Mozart’s 1780 Vesperae Solennes de Confessore K339. The short movements do not dwell on the text and the final Magnificat – so often lovingly enhanced by other composers – is here over almost before it starts. Before that comes the only popular section, the Laudate Dominum for which soprano Sophie Levi provided radiant tone.

On a very blustery night it was encouraging to see a large audience in Christ Church and we can hope this will continue for the next event on 1 December in St Clements, which brings works by Bach, Telemann, Schutz and Buxtehude.

Photos: Peter Mould

Ljubica Stojanic

31 October 2019, Islington

Paul Fincham, composer of The Little Princess, which premiered at Garsington Opera at Wormsley this summer invited me to this private recital by Serbian pianist Ljubica Stojanic in his Islington home. I joined about 30 other like minded people – mostly Fincham’s friends, colleagues and people who sing with him in the London Philharmonic Choir.

It’s a novel joy to hear and enjoy salon music played in a salon. We sat in rows at one end of the house’s large all-through sitting room which Fincham uses as a studio and music room. Stojanic played Bach’s French Overture in its rather lovely entirety including all the movements which are usually omitted. With the piano lid open and Stojanic facing her audience it became a very engaging experience because we felt the music with her intimately.  I admired the way she managed the varied moods, time signatures and tempi with thoughtful silent links. She is, moreover, mistress of Baroque decoration. Rarely have I heard so many grace notes and turns.

Then we repaired to Fincham’s generously proportioned kitchen/dining basement area for a delicious supper (some of the best vegetarian food I’ve ever been offered) before going back upstairs and fast-forwarding nearly 300 years for Rachmaninoff  Preludes Op 23. It was a good choice because they’re a varied set of pieces and Stojanic gave us plenty of colour and mood change all played with precision and warmth. She ran very dramatically with the famous, bouncy number 5 in G minor which worked particularly well after the more lyrical one which preceded it.

The great advantage of hearing this music in a very small space (and with an informed audience) is that you can really hear and appreciate the slow dying away of notes at the end of sections until the release of the sustaining pedal. It fosters attentive listening.

All in all this was a very congenial informal recital and I hope we hear a lot more of the talented Stojanic, still only 24, in the future.

Susan Elkin

Il Barbiere Di Sivilgia: Barefoot Opera

St Mary in the Castle, 26th October 2019

It worked very well indeed!  To set Rossini’s comic opera in a toy museum at night, where the toys become the characters, gave the Stage and Costume designer a free hand; I did like the parts the rag dolls played with the juxtaposition of a rocking horse and an oil drum on stage. The idea also gave Director, Jenny Miller, an opportunity to encourage children, who fitted in very well. And the expansion of the role given to Fiorella /intruder/ Everyman was mimed  brilliantly by Matthew Mahoney.  It all worked, and while the feathers of  some purists may have been ruffled, it was hugely enjoyable.

The setting and atmosphere of St Mary in the Castle helped with the idea of the production. Singers and players entered from the audience or the side; scene shifts were seen and a general informality with what might be termed ‘proper theatre procedure’ fitted well with this delightful enjoyable comedy opera.

But of course it is the character of Figaro who steals the show.  Oscar Catellino did just that. He played the part with relish and talent.   However, the other soloists were not overshadowed. Jack Roberts excelled as Count Almaviva and was as good as a tenor can get.  Mezzo Soprano Rozanna Madylus not only sang Rosina faultlessly but managed, at the appropriate times, to look equally beautiful and ridiculous.   Jon Openshaw and Andrew Sparling were both very convincing as singers and actors. All soloist were excellent and played their parts with obvious enjoyment.  Well done!  A splendid evening of opera with talent, imagination, innovation and energy.

Apparently at the premiere of this opera in 1816 there were several on-stage accidents. And because of this, I am still wondering if the dry ice which set off a cacophony of fire alarms at the beginning of the production was deliberate. But if not, Rossini would have cheerfully sympathised.

Revd Bernard Crosby

 

ENO Orphée: Philip Glass

 

Libretto by the composer based on the film by Jean Cocteau, adaption by Philip Glass edited by Robert Brustein
Conductor, Geoffrey Paterson
Director, Netia Jones

 

English National Opera Stages New Production of Philip Glass’s Orphée

 

Opens Friday 15 November at 7.30pm (6 performances)

 

Following English National Opera’s (ENO) acclaimed Satyagraha and the Olivier Award-winning Akhnaten, this season brings a new staging of Philip Glass’s Orphée to the London Coliseum.

Based on the 1950 Jean Cocteau film of the same name, Glass’s mesmerising opera is directed by Netia Jones, ‘the most imaginative director of opera working in Britain today’ (the Observer), making her ENO debut.

Orphée combines live action and projection, including fragments of Cocteau’s celebrated film.

Netia comments: ‘Orphée is a mirror of a mirror, or a “mise-en-abîme” – an opera of a film of a play of a poem of an opera, in which everything reflects on something else.’

This new production of Orphée uses Cocteau’s film as a starting point, reflecting on Cocteau’s fascination with the mechanics and poetics of film, the life of the artist and ideas of success, failure, ambition, immortality and betrayal.

The production forms part of ENO’s Orpheus series, a reimagining of four operas exploring the Orpheus myth in autumn 2019. Each is interpreted by four directors from diverse theatrical disciplines, all in sets by renowned designer Lizzie Clachan.

Poet Orphée has become passé. Having lost his creative impetus, and becoming implicated in the death of the young and successful poet Cégeste, he becomes obsessed with achieving immortality. Though married to Eurydice, he falls in love with an enigmatic ‘Princess’ and moves between the worlds of the living and the dead. It is only after the Princess sacrifices herself to make Orphée immortal, that he and Eurydice can resume their life together.

Critically acclaimed Nicholas Lester takes the role of Orphée. His previous engagements for ENO were as Marcello in La bohème and Vicomte Cascada in The Merry Widow. He will be joined by another former Merry Widow cast member, Sarah Tynan. ENO favourite Sarah sings her second of two Eurydice roles this season, jumping straight in from a performance in Wayne McGregor’s season opener Orpheus and Eurydice, in which she delivered a performance ‘sung with shining clarity’ (Daily Telegraph).

Established star Nicky Spence joins the cast as Heurtebise, the Princess’s chauffeur. Nicky is a former ENO Harewood Artist whom ENO regulars will recognise as Sergeant Johnny Strong from the world premiere of Ian Bell’s Jack the Ripper: The Women of Whitechapel last season. Soprano Jennifer France makes her ENO debut as the Princess. Trained at the Royal Academy of Music, Jennifer was the recipient of the 2018 Critic’s Circle ‘Emerging Talent (Voice)’ Award.

Anthony Gregory sings Cégeste, combining his strong tenor with a critically praised timbre. The cast is completed by Clive Bayley as the Judge and Simon Shibambu as the Poet, whilst Rachael Lloyd is Aglaonice and William Morgan sings the Reporter.

Geoffrey Paterson conducts. Lighting design is by Lucy Carter and choreography is by Danielle Agami. Video and animation are by Lightmap. Netia Jones and Emma Jenkins have translated the libretto.

The live photographer is Cordula Treml.

 

Orphée opens Friday 15 February at 19.30 at the London Coliseum for 6 performances: 15, 18, 20, 25, 27, 29 November at 19.30.

Victor Willing: Visions

Hastings Contemporary – until 5 January 2020

Hastings Contemporary is still better known to most people in Hastings as formerly the Jerwood Gallery. Hopefully this exceptional new exhibition will change that, for this is the finest use of the spacious building I have encountered since it opened.

The large, ground-floor room serves as an immersive introduction to an artist who has not had a full retrospective since his untimely death in 1988 from multiple-sclerosis. Towards the end of his life he was only able to paint holding the brush in his mouth and nudging it with his left hand. His colours had to be mixed by an assistant. Yet the impact of these late works, particularly the highly poignant portraits, is stunning.

We were privileged at the press showing to be introduced to Victor Willing’s work by his son, film-director Nick Willings who gave us an insight into his father’s approach to painting and the many very real social as well as medical problems he had to overcome. Taught originally at the Slade School, he needed to break away from the straight-jacket of formal painting being taught just after the war, but his style was not accepted, and dismissed as rubbish by conservative critics. He continued indomitably with his desire to paint what he saw in a series of visions, rather than the insistence on representing ‘reality’. It is these visions which form the heart of the exhibition.

The hang at Hastings Contemporary brings together the largest collection of his works ever mounted, with pictures loaned from a wide range of international sources. The vast canvases in the downstairs rooms give way to ones of more modest size but equal interest until one comes to the final portraits, including the deeply moving Self-Portrait at Seventy, as the artist considers what he might become if he had lived to seventy. There are also a collection of nude paintings most of which feature his wife in highly abstract settings, yet full of warmth and intimacy.

If you have possibly hesitated in visiting Hastings Contemporary I can only encourage you to go. The paintings are worth pausing over and the building is now seen at its best.

CDs/DVDs October 2019 (2)

Gluck: Orphee et Euridice
Lyric Opera Chcago, Harry Bicket
CMAJOR 714308

This recording arrived the day after I had been to see ENO’s new production of Gluck’s Orfeo. There were some unexpected parallels. Both dispense with the all-important chorus, replacing them with dancers. This made a little more sense in John Neumeier’s Chicago staging as he has changed Orpheus into a choreographer and re-created the narrative as a nightmare following Eurydice’s death in a car accident. This is somewhat easier to take on DVD where most of the visual impact is in close up than it might be live and the chorus are singing off-stage. Dmitry Korchak brings a strong tenor to the lead part – unusual when so often cast as an alto or counter-tenor. His acting is convincing within the limits of the production and the final scenes are certainly effective. Andriana Chuchman has to dance as well as sing and does so with quite confidence, but the most engaging singing comes from Lauren Snouffer’s delightful Amore.

I am increasingly surprised that opera directors seem to find it impossible today to simply tell a story without having to fill out the psychology in graphic detail. It is as if we have no ability to use our imaginations any more. It seems ok for the cinema to indulge in fantasy but not the stage!

 

Bach Violin Concerti
Kati Debretzeni, violin, English Baroque Soloists, John Eliot Gardiner
SOLI DEO GLORIA SDG 732

A splendidly lively rendition of the two familiar violin concerti and two which lie on the edges of the canon. The A minor BWV 1041 and E major BWV1042 are joined by an arrangement of BWV 1053, originally scored for harpsichord solo and BWV 1052 whose origins have long been argued over – arguments which continue today. No such problem with the outcomes which are convincing in all cases with bright, crisp playing from all concerned and exceptional clarity of line.

 

Virtuosa of Venice
Fieri Consort
FIER003VOV

Female composers are still overlooked today, and early music composers probably more than others. All the more welcome then this disc of works primarily by the 17th century Venetian composer Barbara Strozzi.  She was an acclaimed singer before she started to compose and these works sit beautifully for the voice. They are light and captivating, and the voices are accompanied by a small chamber ensemble of viola da gamba, theorbo and baroque harp.

 

Tchaikovsky: Symphony No 5
Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks, Mariss Jansons
BR KLASSIK 900104

This cd is linked to the new catalogue from BR and is a strong indication of their overall approach to recording. Taken from a live broadcast, it has all the frisson one could hope for and a great deal of exciting playing. Maris Jansons is a key conductor for the label and continues to impress with his ability to see an entire series of works as a whole.

 

Beethoven: Piano Concertos 1 & 2
Boris Giltburg, piano;  Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra, Vasily Petrenko
NAXOS 8.574151
Beethoven: Piano Concertos 0, 2 & 6

Sophie-Mayuko Vetter, piano / fortepiano; Hamburg Symphony Orchestra, Peter Ruzicka

Two releases of Beethoven’s Second Piano Concerto – though on this occasion we have to be very careful about the titles. It is a familiar truth that the second concerto pre-dates the first, but less well known that there was an even earlier concerto, written when the composer was only 14. This has become known at No0 and is here recorded on an 1806 fortepiano which brings it to life in a highly convincing way. At the other end of his life, Beethoven had started work on a sixth concerto, though little of it survives. Here we have an opulent Allegro completed by Nicholas Cook and Hermann Dechant. Effectively, Beethoven intended to compose seven piano concerto rather than the five we conventionally know.  Strong performances on each disc though I am particularly glad to hear the two rarer works.

 

Dohnanyi: Symphony No1
Deutsche Staatsphilharmonie Rheinland-Pfalz, Roberto Paternostro
CAPRICCIO C5386

This recording of the first symphony is coupled with the five Symphonic Minutes Op36. The symphony was written in 1901 at a time when the composer had achieved early success. Though his name is still familiar to us, the symphony certainly isn’t and it quickly becomes obvious why this might be so. The work is finely scored and has much warmly rich writing, but the actual melodic ideas don’t abide in the memory and the overall impact is somewhat less than its parts. The cover photo is striking but seems to have nothing to do with the works recorded!

 

Mahler: Symphony No4
Radio-Sinfonieorchester Stuttgart des SWR, Roger Norrington
SWR MUSIC SWR19524CD

Another live performance from 2005 with all the vigour and immediacy that one might expect from both orchestra and conductor.  Anu Komsi is a gentle soloist at the end and brings the symphony to a reflective end.

 

Avet Rubeni Terterian: Symphonies 3 & 4
Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra, Kirill Karabits
CHANDOS CHSA 5241

I found that the way in to these two symphonies is very much through the two extra items between them. Two short works for duduks (an Armenian double-reed instrument) give the folk background and something of the feel of the works before one launches into the symphonies which are both highly charged and demanding. They are worth the effort of investigating but I doubt if they would ever sit happily within the western musical tradition.

 

Darkness Illuminated; works by Scriabin and Stanchinsky
Nafis Umerkulova, piano
UA UA0012

The fascinating items here are the works by Stanchinsky, a name all but unknown in Britain. They sit very comfortably alongside the works by Scriabin which may be more familiar – if only stylistically. Most of these are short pieces but none the less demanding on both player and listener, though very much worth the effort. Nafis Umerkulova is a highly convincing exponent and a delight to listen to.

 

 

 

Hastings Early Music Festival – 3

Kino Teatr, Sunday 20 October 2019

The final performance in this year’s festival came from the Consone Quartet, returning after their involvement in the fine Bach evening which opened the festival. They are BBC New Generation Artists for the 2019-21 season and are the only period-instrument string quartet ever to have been accepted into the scheme.

Their programme bridged the period between Boccherini and Schumann, demonstrating with great clarity and beauty the development of the quartet over that time span. They opened with Schubert’s early String Quartet in C D32, with its fresh intensity and exuberant sense of vitality. This was followed by Haydn’s early quartet Op20 No4. The richness of tone in the opening movement was an indication of the particular warmth of gut strings, and this continued to be marked for the rest of the quartet, even in the skittish final movement.

After the interval we heard Boccherini’s brief quartet Op33 No5, which only extends to two movements but has fine changes of dynamic intensity and liveliness. The final work was Schumann’s quartet No2 Op41. Here we are on the verge of modern instrumentation but there was good reason to set it within the context of the earlier works and on original instruments, for it rapidly becomes clear that Schumann is hearing the instruments quite differently to the way we do today and thus the expectations of the listener are quite different. It was equally clear that the acoustic in the Kino Teatr was an essential part of the experience and one which helped both the ambience and intimacy of the event. This young quartet has made a very strong impression in a very short time and looks (and sounds!) certain to continue to be highly successful.

The festival was over all too soon. Next year is the big Beethoven anniversary and promises to be equally enthralling.